You’re reading an issue of The Luthier’s Letter. Every Saturday morning I share practical tips, techniques, & lessons from my guitar-building bench to help you grow as a luthier. Join thousands of guitar builders learning the art of lutherie: Subscribe free โ†’

I saw a short clip of John Mayer a while back, and something he said has stayed with me.

In it, he says there’s the way it is, and then there’s the way it seems, and that he’s willing to bet that 99% of our problems come from the way it seems.

His advice is to find a friend you trust. Every once in a while, when something feels off, you ask them, “Hey, how is it?” Then you believe them when they tell you it’s alright.

What I love about that little clip is that he says in half a minute what took me years of building to learn. I could have saved myself a lot of sleepless nights if I’d understood it sooner.

A few weeks ago I asked where you were feeling stuck in your guitar building. And when I read what some of you wrote about finding the time and space to build, I thought about that clip again.

“Time and space are my biggest problems right now.”

That’s how Larry put it in his reply, and he wasn’t alone. Some of you don’t have a shop yet. Some of you are waiting for life to slow down, or for one more project to be finished first. Some of you are still getting your tools together.

Steve wrote, “I’ve spent more time acquiring and making tools than actually working on the guitar.”

I’ve been there too, and I can see now what John Mayer meant.

Here’s the way it seems: Before I can build a guitar, I need a proper shop, every tool, and a long stretch of free time.

That sounds pretty reasonable. Then I think about where I built my first guitar and how close I came to not building it at all.

It was 1997, and I was in music school. I carved most of it standing at my kitchen counter, and I glued it together on the kitchen table. I wasn’t married yet, which probably helped. ๐Ÿ™‚

My next workbench was a sheet of plywood laid across two sawhorses I borrowed from my dad. I built three more guitars on it. It wasn’t a good bench, but it was good enough.

After that came a wobbly bench made of particleboard and Masonite. It was years before I built the workbench I have now. That’s the one I love working at, and I still find myself giving it a tap as I walk by. For something so big and heavy, it has this warm, woody ping that I never get tired of hearing.

But my guitars didn’t wait for that workbench.

From the kitchen counter on, I learned something with each guitar that made the next one a little better. Whenever I had extra time or money, it went into the guitars.

Even now, my shop is only about 400 square feet. And I’ve seen some wonderfully resourceful setups from members of my online school, the Luthier’s EDGE. One member builds on an apartment balcony. Others have found room for a workbench right behind the living room couch.

You don’t need a big shop, and you don’t need every tool, either. You just need enough room to work and the right tools for the step you’re on.

So why does it seem like we need more?

I think we draw a box around ourselves without even realizing it. We hear about “thinking outside the box” as if it took a genius. Often it’s as simple as getting curious about something we’ve always taken for granted.

“I don’t have a shop” may be perfectly true. It’s the “so I can’t start yet” part I’ve learned to question. Is there some part of this guitar I could work on in the space I do have?

When I ask that, I usually find that the box isn’t real.

Sometimes other people hand us the box. More often, at least in my case, I draw it myself. That kind is the hardest to spot, because it feels like a fact. It also does the most damage. Fortunately, it’s the one we have the most power to change.

I’m great at drawing those boxes ๐Ÿ™‚
I think we all are.

I’ve drawn that box around my time, too.

Matt from Connecticut wrote that, with other projects still to finish, he’s “frightened to start and then to have to stop and leave it.”

I know that feeling all too well. For me, it took the form of an idea I’d convinced myself of somewhere along the way: that I needed whole days at the bench to get any real work done.

My weeks were filling up with other things, like courses to film and letters to write. So I blocked out Thursday and Friday, twelve hours or more each, and tried to fit all of the week’s guitar making into those two days.

It seemed like a good plan. It wasn’t. By Wednesday night, the pressure was already mounting: I’d better get it all done, or I’ve lost the week. I was rushed for two days straight, and however much I got through, I ended the week feeling I had failed.

I can laugh about it now.

The trouble went deeper than just feeling rushed. You can’t listen when you’re under that much pressure. I couldn’t slow down enough to sense what the wood was telling me or to think clearly, and that’s when I was at risk of making bad decisions or mistakes.

What works far better for me is to save my mornings for building guitars. That’s when I’m most focused. Some days I’ll push lunch back and spend six hours or more at the bench. When I’m filming, I might move it to later in the day. Sometimes I only get an hour, but I have my hands on a guitar nearly every day, and that keeps me connected and the work moving.

Consistency beats intensity.

And because I know I’ll be back tomorrow, I don’t have to finish everything today.

Even on the day I wrote this letter, I prepped my shop and sharpened my chisels and plane irons (my mise en place). I knew I’d be working on my new archtop the next morning, and I wanted to start with everything sharp and ready.

Here’s one thing I’ve learned about having to “stop and leave it”: stopping is a whole lot easier if I know where I’ll pick up again.

Ernest Hemingway would stop writing for the day while he still knew what came next, and I do something similar in the shop. Near the end of a session I look for a point where the next step is clear. I stop there, write that step down, and let the work go. Often a new idea or a solution turns up between sessions, while I’m cooking dinner or taking a walk.

I wrote about this way of stopping in The Hemingway Bridge Method.

Saving my mornings is what fits my life right now. What fits yours will look different, and it will change with your family, your work, and whatever a particular guitar throws at you. The only way I know to find what fits is to try things and pay attention to what happens. Even the plans that failed taught me something I couldn’t have worked out in my head.

Then there are the times when it’s hard to get started.

In The War of Art, Steven Pressfield calls that Resistance. To me it’s like trying to push the north poles of two magnets together. It hasn’t gone away after nearly thirty years of building, maybe because I now know more things that can go wrong than I did when I started.

So I use what I call the ten-minute trick. I tell myself I’ll work on a job for ten minutes, and then I’m allowed to stop.

And I mean it. If ten minutes go by and I still don’t want to be there, I let that task go for the day and pick up something with less pressure.

The funny thing is, I hardly ever do. Ten minutes turn into thirty, and by then I don’t want to stop. I know exactly what I’m doing to myself, and it works anyway.

Here are three ways I use it in the shop:

  • When the shop is a mess, I clean for ten minutes. I straighten one shelf, and then I want to do the next one.
  • Before a step that makes me nervous, I warm up on scrap. I heat the bending iron and bend an offcut. Or I clamp a board to the bench and rout a binding channel in it, exactly as I plan to rout the real one. After that I’m usually ready to do it on the guitar.
  • When I’m not sure where to begin, I pick something small. I look over the blueprint, do some sketching, or pick up the piece I’ve been working on and tap it.

Each of these gets me out of my head and into the shop. Try one this week, and see how you feel at minute eleven.

The ten-minute trick gets me going when I can’t seem to begin. But sometimes we get stuck and can’t see a way forward. After a while, it can start to feel like there just isn’t one.

That’s where the other part of the John Mayer clip comes in.

Sometimes it takes a friend to help us see what we’ve missed.

It matters who you ask, though. I almost didn’t build my first guitar because of what one person told me.

In 1995, I bought Guitarmaking: Tradition and Technology by William Cumpiano and Jonathan Natelson because I wanted to build a guitar of my own. I asked a guitar tech I knew if he thought I could do it. He said, “It’s way too hard. Don’t waste your time. You’re not going to be able to build one that’s any good.”

I don’t blame him. I think he was giving me his honest opinion. We didn’t know each other well, and he had no idea I’d grown up doing carpentry with my dad. As far as I know, he’d never built a guitar himself.

Part of me still believed I could do it, but I figured he knew better.

The box was his, and I climbed into it.

I put the idea away and bought a guitar instead.

But the idea came back. I remember showing up at music school with my old Fender Strat and my acoustic, ready to study jazz guitar. Everyone around me seemed to have a beautiful archtop, and the more I played, the more I wanted one of my own. I was working my way through school, so buying an archtop was out of reach.

Around then I met a luthier named Mike King. When I told him I wanted to build one, he said, “Yeah, you can do it.” He also let me come to his shop and use the tools I didn’t have.

Part of me had always believed I could build a guitar. But it made all the difference to hear it from someone who’d actually done it. And that’s how I ended up standing at my kitchen counter, carving that first guitar.

At the time, I thought what I needed from Mike was access to his tools. Looking back, what I needed more was someone to turn to when I got stuck. He was the friend John Mayer was talking about. That’s a big part of why I started the Luthier’s EDGE, and I love getting to be that person for other builders.

Thank you to everyone who wrote to me over these past few weeks. It means a lot that you’d tell me where you’re stuck.

And if you’re still wondering whether you can build a guitar with the time and space you have, I’ll tell you what Mike told me:

Yeah, you can do it.

Sapere Aude ยท Creare Aude

Tom

P.P.S. Next week’s letter will come a day early, on Black Friday morning. It’s about tools: the ones worth having when you’re getting started, and the ones that can wait.